← Medical education

Reading a case report: what happened and what supports it?

Use a library case to separate observations, diagnostic evidence and outcomes.

Identify the person and the stage of care

Identify the age at assessment, presenting concern, history and reason for publication. Put assessment, diagnosis, intervention and follow-up in order.

A condition recognized at puberty may concern development that occurred earlier. Recognition and onset are not interchangeable.

Sources: [1] CARE · Case-report checklist

Connect the diagnosis to the observation

For DSD-C01, the chromosome test establishes 46,XX, while histology identifies ovarian and testicular tissue. They support different parts of the description. Imaging, operative observations and pathology also need to be distinguished.

A useful note has four parts: conclusion, test, finding and source location.

Sources: [2] Cureus (2021) · Original ovotesticular DSD case

A plan is not a completed intervention or an outcome

A planned procedure, a completed procedure and an outcome at one year are different statements. A discharge summary does not establish a long-term outcome.

A paper that does not mention a complication has not necessarily assessed and excluded it.

Sources: [1] CARE · Case-report checklist

What can this report tell us?

A case can illustrate an unusual presentation or a diagnostic difficulty. It usually cannot compare treatment effectiveness or estimate a population probability.

Use it to develop a question, then examine other reports, cohorts or relevant guidance.

Sources: [1] CARE · Case-report checklist; [2] Cureus (2021) · Original ovotesticular DSD case

Does a planned reconstruction establish a good postoperative outcome?

No. A plan, a completed intervention and an observed outcome are separate facts.

Original studies and references