← Back to guided cases

Connect mechanisms to observations

Does a hormone level establish its action?

The source describes a 25-year-old presenting with primary amenorrhea. Add one type of evidence at a time and examine the basis for each inference.

Observations come from the selected release’s case summary; teaching explanations are separate. Follow the fields and publication links to check the original.

Step 1

Start with imaging

Age

25 years

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 1
Imaging

Ultrasound no uterus / visible gonads; MRI showed no utero-vagina, bilateral inguinal testis-like structures

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 2
What does imaging most directly describe?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

Imaging provides anatomical clues, not a receptor-function or molecular diagnosis. A testis-like structure on imaging is an observation to consider with other evidence.

Answer: Observed internal structures and their positions.

Check the original publication
Step 2

Add the karyotype

Karyotype

46,XY

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 2
Does 46,XY establish the entire developmental mechanism?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

Different mechanisms can occur with the same karyotype. Continue examining hormone production, hormone action and gonadal evidence.

Answer: No, hormone, tissue and other evidence still matter.

Check the original publication
Step 3

Examine the hormone findings

Laboratory findings

Key labs/hormones: elevated FSH/LH, decreased estradiol, normal testosterone (see original; reference: see original; time point: visit / as noted in text)

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 2
Can the recorded testosterone result alone establish normal androgen action?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

The result describes a circulating concentration. Tissue response requires other evidence; this exercise supplies no universal cutoff for other individuals.

Answer: No, concentration and receptor action are different layers.

Check the original publication
Step 4

Read the reported diagnosis

Reported diagnosis

Complete androgen insensitivity syndrome

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 2
How should the reported diagnosis be read?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

The authors report complete androgen insensitivity syndrome. Relate that conclusion to chromosome, anatomical and hormone findings. Do not add molecular confirmation that is not supplied.

Answer: Consider the observations together and check the source's evidence and limitations.

Check the original publication
Step 5

Bound the outcome claim

Follow-up record

No complications at 1 month; married 1 year later and achieved satisfactory sexual life using neovagina

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 2
What statement can one case's follow-up support?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

Keep the reported time point and scope explicit. Comparative effectiveness and long-term effects require additional research.

Answer: The observation in that individual at the reported time.

Check the original publication

Connect the evidence

Case recap

  • Imaging, chromosomes and hormones answer different questions.
  • A hormone concentration alone does not establish normal tissue response.
  • An individual's follow-up cannot establish population-level effectiveness.

For your next case, write down: conclusion, assessment, observation, source and what remains unknown.

Continue with the mechanisms