← Back to guided cases

Distinguish layers of evidence

What can a karyotype tell us?

This report describes the assessment of a 21-month-old child. Read each observation before deciding what it supports.

Observations come from the selected release’s case summary; teaching explanations are separate. Follow the fields and publication links to check the original.

Step 1

Start with the observations

Age

21 months

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 1
Clinical observations

Mildly virilized phallic structure with hypospadias opening at the perineum; labioscrotal folds; non-palpable bilateral gonads, Prader stage IV.

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 2
Do these external findings establish the gonadal tissue type?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

These observations describe age and external findings. Identifying tissue requires evidence about that tissue. Separate an observation from an inference.

Answer: No, evidence from other assessments is needed.

Check the original publication
Step 2

Add the chromosome result

Karyotype

46,XX

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 6
Which question does this result directly answer?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

46,XX is a chromosome finding. It does not by itself report gonadal histology, hormone function or a fertility outcome.

Answer: What chromosome constitution this test reported.

Check the original publication
Step 3

Examine the tissue evidence

Pathology

Right bipolar ovotestis with approximately 50% ovarian and 50% testicular tissue; no tumor on pathology; fertility potential score of the testicular tissue was 0.

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 6
Which evidence directly supports the tissue definition of ovotesticular DSD?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

The pathology supplies tissue evidence. Tissue type and the production of hormones or mature gametes remain different questions.

Answer: Histological identification of both ovarian and testicular tissue.

Check the original publication
Step 4

Separate a plan from an outcome

Follow-up record

Exploration and biopsy sampling completed; the family chose male rearing, with staged reconstruction planned subsequently.

Check the case fieldRecorded source page(s) 8
Does a plan for later reconstruction establish a good long-term outcome?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

A plan describes an intention. Record completed care and results at a stated follow-up separately; do not fill in long-term outcomes.

Answer: No, completion and follow-up need their own evidence.

Check the original publication
Step 5

Check what is missing

Laboratory findings

Complete hormone values not provided in the case narrative of the original article.

Check the case field
How should incomplete hormone values in a case summary be recorded?
Read the teaching explanation

Teaching explanation

Missing information is not a normal result. Use the case fields and original paper to check what the authors actually reported.

Answer: Keep the information missing and check the original source.

Check the original publication

Connect the evidence

Case recap

  • Chromosomes, tissue and function need separate evidence.
  • Histology describes tissue; it does not replace functional assessment.
  • Keep plans, completed interventions and observed outcomes separate.

For your next case, write down: conclusion, assessment, observation, source and what remains unknown.

Continue with the mechanisms